I've been chipping away and finished off another draft of a song, but I'm reaching the point of frustration once more. I am never sure when this happens whether to take a few songs and delete them mercilessly or whether it would be better to suck it up and finish them (because probably I'll like them later.)
I'm going to do an analysis (alphabetical) of the songs that I HAVE finished for my future reference. Maybe the next time I write a musical I'll be able to look back and see which creative processes seem to be the most succesful. Half will be posted today, and half on Sunday.
A Love That Will Never Die- I like this song very much. It's very simple and not at all in my style, and was semi difficult to write. I got the idea while actually holding a guitar (a first!) and made up a nice guitar melody off of two slurred notes that I played while holding it. The refrain came naturally and quickly, and the whole skeleton may have been written in just a few hours. The vocal melody was a great deal more difficult, and that took a few revisions- I'm happy with it now.
A Vision- This is the song based on some verses from "Kubla Khan" (which was inspired by an opium induced-dream, as I've recently learned). I wrote this song early in the summer (EDIT: I just checked my blog, and found out that I wrote it in August, so that's a lie. I have a terrible memory), so I can't recall too much of the process, but if I recall correctly it was very easy to start and very difficult to finish. There are five drafts of openings that I have stored somewhere. The one I settled on goes from simple to complex, but I don't know if it does so in any sort of interesting way. One of the songs, along with Alone and Silence, that I am most uncertain about.
Alone- I worked up several unsuccessful starts to this song before finally stealing a guitar melody that I had intended for Ballad back in April or May. I got some minor ideas for a glockenspiel (which I'm not sure I'll keep) after listening to "Spring Awakening." The refrain was influenced from a french film called "Les Choristes," and is basically just a sequence of scales going higher and higher that I've always wanted to throw in to a song. I'm not sure about the end of the refrain, because it just stops suddenly at the climax. It could be effective. Maybe not. The vocal melody was easy to write, but it might be a little low. I need to hear it sung before I make a final judgement.
The Ballad of Annabel Lee-
One of the two hardest songs to write in the entire play. I struggled for weeks with the awkward rhythm of the verses. Poe does not lend himself well to musical settings, which is probably why you don't hear about them being done. There are twelve versions of this song, including three that were completed. The first was too slow, the second was too evil, and the third I think has finally struck the balance between haunting, beautiful, and urgent that the piece really needs. The song does everything that it needs to do. I don't think that it's the best melody in the show, and I don't think that it's the best harmony and orchestration... but I do think that it's perfect for what it needs to do.
The Ballad of Annabel Lee (Reprise)-
This just steals the melody from Annabel Lee and makes it more evil. Songs are easy to write when you know what the melody HAS to be and then just have to incorporate a general mood. It needs to be lengthened for the storm sequence, but overall one of the easier songs to write.
Close to Death-
It's good that I've done this analysis, because I looked back on all of my posts to see if I could find information about these songs, and I have never once mentioned Close to Death. It's a piece that occurs after Madeline has "died" and is put in the tomb alongside Annabel Lee. It recaps both Ballad and Alone at the same time, and adds a third melody (which is new) to complement the two. I have no clue when I wrote this song, though it must have been early August. I remember having one very productive week back then. For a very complicated song, the writing came very easily. It could have been, again, that my melodies were very clear and set and all I had to do was figure out how to put them together. Starting from nothing is always much harder to do. I think this is a very cool, epic song.
That's it for now. I look forward to Sunday so I can see other ways that my brain has been lying to me about what I did this summer.